NAPLAN Pros and Cons: An Honest Guide for Parents
VCI Team
28 Oct 2026 · 8 min read

Few topics divide Australian parents like NAPLAN. Some see a useful national health-check for literacy and numeracy. Others see stressed children, narrowed teaching and league tables. We teach children who sit NAPLAN every year, and our honest view is that both sides are partly right. This guide lays out the genuine benefits, the genuine drawbacks, and the question parents ask us most: is extra preparation — including tutoring — actually worth it?
What NAPLAN is meant to do
NAPLAN is a national assessment for Years 3, 5, 7 and 9 covering Writing, Reading, Conventions of Language and Numeracy. Its stated purpose is measurement, not ranking: to show parents how their child is progressing against national standards, to show schools where teaching is working, and to show governments where support is needed. It is not an entrance exam, it does not decide grades or class placements, and no child "fails" it. Those facts matter when weighing the debate, because much of the anxiety around NAPLAN comes from treating it as something it is not.
The pros — what NAPLAN genuinely does well
- It catches gaps early. A child can drift a year behind in reading or number skills while school reports still sound reassuring. NAPLAN compares your child with a national standard, so a quiet problem becomes visible while there is still plenty of time to fix it.
- It gives parents independent information. School reports vary enormously in style and candour. A NAPLAN report is one consistent, external reference point you can track across Years 3, 5, 7 and 9.
- It keeps literacy and numeracy central. Reading, writing and number skills underpin every other subject. A national check on exactly those skills is a reasonable priority for an education system.
- The results are actionable. Because each domain is reported separately in plain proficiency levels — Exceeding, Strong, Developing, Needs additional support — you can see whether the issue is reading, spelling, writing structure or maths, and respond to that specific thing.
- It is the same test for everyone. Whatever its flaws, a common measure across states, sectors and schools gives families who move — interstate or from overseas — a comparable benchmark.
The cons — where the critics have a point
- Test anxiety is real. Some children, especially in Year 3, experience genuine stress. Much of it is imported — children absorb adult tension — but not all of it, and schools that hype the test make it worse.
- It is one day, one snapshot. A child who slept badly, is unwell, or simply freezes can produce a result well below their real level. Treating any single NAPLAN result as the full truth about a child is a mistake.
- Teaching to the test narrows learning. When weeks of class time go to practice papers, children lose rich teaching — and, ironically, drilling is a poor way to build the skills the test measures anyway.
- League tables misuse the data. Comparing schools by raw NAPLAN scores ignores intake differences and pushes schools toward the behaviours above. This is a criticism of how results are used, more than of the test itself — but it is a fair one.
- It measures a narrow slice. Creativity, science inquiry, collaboration, persistence — much of what makes a successful student is not in NAPLAN, and a good result is not a guarantee of anything beyond solid literacy and numeracy.
So — is extra tutoring for NAPLAN worth it?
Here is our honest answer, and it is not "always yes" — which would be convenient for a tutoring company to say.
Cramming is not worth it. Weeks of drilling practice papers to squeeze a few extra marks teaches test tricks, bores children, and inflates a score without fixing anything. If a service sells NAPLAN preparation as intensive test rehearsal, save your money.
Steady skill-building is worth it — because NAPLAN measures real skills. Unlike a trivia test, NAPLAN cannot really be gamed: it tests whether a child can read and understand, write in organised paragraphs, spell common patterns, and reason with numbers. Improving those things improves NAPLAN results as a side effect — and, far more importantly, improves everything else the child studies for years afterwards. That kind of help is not "NAPLAN tutoring" so much as good tutoring that March happens to measure.
For a child who is doing well, extra tutoring for NAPLAN alone is usually unnecessary. If your child's reading is a daily habit and their school reports are solid, the best NAPLAN preparation is a calm term and a good night's sleep. Spend the money on books they'll love instead.
For a child with real gaps, help is worthwhile — start early. If last year's report, teacher feedback or a previous NAPLAN shows Developing or Needs additional support, that is information worth acting on in January, not February. Skills grow slowly; the earlier start is what makes improvement — rather than cramming — possible. If you are not sure how big the gaps really are, a free trial class answers that question honestly in a single lesson. Our 2027 prep schedule shows what a calm timeline looks like.
How to keep NAPLAN in proportion
- Talk about it as a check-up, like a dental visit — useful information, not a judgement.
- Never use the words pass or fail. NAPLAN has neither; it has proficiency levels.
- Read the results for the pattern, not the headline: which domain, which direction since last time. Our results guide walks through exactly how.
- If a result surprises you, ask the teacher before worrying — they see your child every day, and can tell you whether the snapshot matches the child they know.
- Keep preparation inside normal life: reading together, maths in cooking and shopping, writing for real reasons. That is preparation, and it never feels like pressure.
Our position, in one sentence: NAPLAN is a useful measuring tool and a poor master. Use its results to find and fix real gaps — with school, at home, or with support like our 1-to-1 NAPLAN tutoring if the gaps are specific — and then get on with the broader business of your child learning things. If you are unsure whether your child even has gaps worth acting on, a free trial class will tell you plainly, and we will tell you if we think they do not need tutoring at all.
The view from the classroom
Talk to teachers about NAPLAN and a nuanced picture emerges — one that rarely survives the louder public debate. Most teachers we encounter value the data: a standardised result can confirm what they suspected about a student, or flag a child whose quiet classroom performance had hidden a gap. Many also resent the pressure that published school comparisons create, and the practice-paper weeks that creep into Term 1 because of it. In other words, the profession's position looks much like the parents' position in this guide: the measurement is useful; the mythology around it is not. Holding both halves of that view at once is, we would suggest, the healthiest way for a family to approach March — prepare the skills, ignore the noise.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the questions parents ask us most about this topic.
The test itself is a few hours across two weeks. What harms children is the anxiety adults sometimes build around it and weeks of drilling. Kept in proportion, most children treat it as a mildly unusual school day.
Schools expect all students in Years 3, 5, 7 and 9 to participate. Exemptions exist for some students with significant disability or very recent arrival from a non-English-speaking background, and parents can formally withdraw a child. Talk to your school early if you are considering it.
No. NAPLAN is separate from school assessment and reporting. Teachers may use results as one input among many, but it does not set grades.
A little familiarisation is sensible — children should meet the online format before the day. Extended drilling usually reflects pressure from published comparisons rather than good pedagogy, and it is the part of the system most worth criticising.
Not on its own. Raw results reflect student intake as much as teaching quality. Growth between a child's successive NAPLAN years is a fairer signal than any single score.
No. Treat it as a question, not a verdict: which domain, and does it match what the teacher sees? Then build a calm plan for that skill. Our guide to what each domain tests helps you pinpoint it.
Tutoring that improves the underlying skills improves results, because the test measures those skills. Tutoring that only rehearses test technique produces, at best, a small and temporary bump — and often just a stressed child.
Daily reading, regular times-table practice, and normal family routines in the test weeks. It is unglamorous, and it is most of what works.
VCI Team
The Virtual Career Institute team of certified tutors and education specialists — helping students across the UK, Australia, Saudi Arabia, UAE, USA, Qatar, and Canada achieve their academic goals.
Need help with this topic?
Book a Free Trial


